By Louisa Baczor, Research Advisor at the CIPD
Toxic workplace cultures have recently been very prominent in public debate. Last year’s scandals included allegations of bullying and harassment in Westminster, and the exposure of Sir Philip Green’s use of non-disclosure agreements to cover up claims of abuse by employees. Most recently, staff at Ted Baker launched a petition to complain about the CEO’s inappropriate behaviour and ‘forced hugging’. These revelations have raised pertinent questions around how organisations can create environments in which individuals feel safe and supported to speak up. This is important not only because of the reputational and financial risks to organisations in failing to properly address these workplace issues. Employers should not overlook the impact on the workers themselves.
Psychological safety in the workplace is employees’ feelings about taking risks and sharing thoughts with others in the organisation, and it provides a bedrock for employee voice. Before an individual speaks up, they make a judgement about whether doing so will be effective, and assess any risks or potential negative outcomes they may face as a result. As you’d expect, people are more likely to remain silent if they believe that the costs of speaking up outweigh the benefits – for example, if they feel that nothing would be done about it, or that their position in the organisation would be threatened. A Unions21 report found that many low-skilled young professionals feel they’re treated unfairly at work, but a lack of empowerment means speaking up could harm their career prospects, so they opt for leaving the company instead.
Power dynamics can therefore be a significant barrier to voice. Individuals may have great ideas to improve the way things are done in the organisation and foster innovation, but hold back because they worry about being judged negatively or treading on the toes of a more senior colleague. While preventing important suggestions and issues from being raised, this can harm their sense of well-being and motivation at work.
So, how can employers provide opportunities for all workers to speak up on matters that are important to them? Like so many areas of people management practice, managerial behaviour has a vital role to play. While they may have good intentions about encouraging people to openly share their feelings, line managers may inadvertently show attitudes or behaviour that discourage voice. For example, they may appear too busy or stressed to discuss personal matters. This points to the need for all managers to be trained to understand the value of employee voice and the impact of their leadership style on individuals’ ability to voice issues.
Our upcoming research with Nottingham Business School provides insight on people’s experience of speaking up at work, and the factors which enable or prevent them from doing so. This is based on a new employee survey and is due to be launched at the end of February.
Thank you for your comments. There may be a short delay in this going live on the blog page as we moderate the comments added to our blogs.
Generally, i think it is all dependent upon your line manager and the work environment. I always ensure that I create a positive work environment for my staff so they have no problem speaking their mind to me - even when they are being critical! Feedback is key for a business owner!
I have been part of two organisations where one really could not speak one's mind unless one would be certain that it would be in line with what the management was expecting/wanted to hear. It is safe to say that it did not boost creativity and it certainly limited the new paths explored. The ones that are thriving in such an environment would be the yea-sayers that never would challenge an idea coming from management, which surprisingly often goes undetected. It is never a healthy position for either the company or the staff, but I cannot see any simple solution to the problem as the topic concern humans. That is why I decided to be self-employed.
Self-Employed at Lasserk
there seems to be a technical glitch - —— sparing no time for calm and casual discussions on employee feelings or feedback. Notwithstanding this situation, I also believe it is imperative that employees be “educated” on how to provide feedback; for instance I have witnessed cases of aggressive and harsh feedback in a crowd in a disrespectful manner and with hard feelings and not supported by facts. Even if it might be against the leadership I am of the view that an open licence to employee voice may warrant minimal rules and ring fencing
* my apologies for breaking this post
My views on this interesting debate are as follows First providing and receiving feedback are important and crucial for a healthy and engaging work environment; moreover, encouraging such practices fosters sense of belonging and boosts up employee participation and sense of recognition and of being valued. I agree that at times managers and leaders may be sending inappropriate signals to feedback by being busy and sparing no time for calm and casual discussions on how the employee fees
Subscribe to the CIPD Newsletter