Selected cases on disability discrimination in the workplace
For UK employment purposes, disability is defined as a physical or mental impairment which has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on a person's ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. It covers physical disability, some medical conditions and mental illness. Disability discrimination has been illegal in the UK since 1995, with the law now incorporated into the Equality Act 2010.
This factsheet looks at the different types of discrimination with examples of how they apply to disability discrimination. It suggests good employment practices to ensure everyone has fair access and opportunity to progress in work, such as making reasonable adjustments to accommodate the needs of a disabled individual. It also encourages employers to challenge stereotypical thinking and provides recommendations for positive progress.
What is disability?
Disability is defined differently for different purposes. For employment purposes in the UK, the definition is contained in the Equality Act 2010: a person is ‘disabled’ if they have a physical or mental impairment which has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on their ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.
‘Long-term’ means that the condition must last, or be likely to last, for more than 12 months, or is likely to last for the rest of the life of the person affected.
Individuals with cancer, multiple sclerosis or HIV/AIDS are covered from the date of diagnosis regardless of the impact that the illness is having on their life at the time of diagnosis. The definition of disability is therefore very broad. This means that many other conditions could also potentially be covered, including, for example, chronic fatigue syndrome, schizophrenia, arthritis, diabetes, epilepsy, dyslexia, severe nut allergies, eczema, depression.
To be covered under the Act, a condition doesn’t have to be clinically well-recognised or diagnosed. Employers should focus on the effects an employee is experiencing at work, not on the disability or condition from which those symptoms may emerge. Many people with a disability or condition which could potentially be covered by the Act may not necessarily identify as or consider themselves to be ’disabled‘, even though they may still need adjustments to support them in the workplace. In practice, this means that employers may need to make adjustments for employees who do not say or think they are ’disabled‘.
The UK has around seven million people of working age with a disability or long-term health condition, yet only about half of them are in work. This represents a huge pool of untapped talent which businesses can’t afford to ignore – read about closing the disability employment gap. Furthermore, research by the TUC found a disability pay gap of 20% with disabled employees earning £2.10 less an hour on average than non-disabled employees.
The impact of coronavirus on disabled people
The COVID-19 pandemic has been felt acutely by those with disabilities and long-term health conditions. Not only are many disabled people clinically at high risk from the virus, but many also work in sectors hardest hit by the outbreak, including retail and hospitality. According to a report from Leonard Cheshire, 71% of disabled people in employment in March this year were affected by the pandemic, either through a loss of income, being put on furlough or being made redundant. This increased to 84% for those aged 18 to 24.
The increase in homeworking opportunities can, however, be helpful for those with disabilities and long-term health conditions. A recent Unison survey found that 73% of disabled workers said they were more or just as productive working from home, owing to reduced pain and fatigue through less commuting, and having the ability to take additional breaks and later start times. However, of those who said they were less productive, more than half, had not been given any reasonable adjustments to support them to work from home. Coronavirus guidance on reasonable adjustments from the Equalities and Human Rights Commission provides helpful advice for employers on properly supporting employees with disabilities or long-term health conditions.
There’s more on what employers should be doing in our Responding to the coronavirus hub.
The UK legal position
In Great Britain, discrimination on the grounds of disability, originally introduced by the Disability Discrimination Act 1995, is now contained within the Equality Act 2010.
The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has published guidance on disability discrimination and the Equality Act including a Code of practice on employment. Whilst not legally binding, the codes give important guidance on good practice and failing to follow them may be taken into account by tribunals or courts. CIPD members can find out more in our Disability discrimination law Q&As.
Our Brexit hub has more on what the implications of leaving the EU might be for UK employment law.
Types of discrimination
Within the Equality Act 2010 there are a number of different types of discrimination. These apply to the protected characteristics, which include disability.
This applies to all protected characteristics. It's treating someone less favourably than another person because of a protected characteristic that they have. For example, it's deciding not to recruit an individual because they are disabled.
Indirect discrimination occurs when:
- a provision, criterion or practice is applied to all, and:
- it puts a group with a protected characteristic at a disadvantage when compared with another group
- an individual is put at a disadvantage
- the employer cannot show it to be a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
For example, indirect disability discrimination could occur if all employees are required to arrive at work at 08:00 and someone who is disabled has difficulty travelling in the rush hour to arrive on time. That employee’s working hours could be changed so they could start and finish later. Enforcing the specific hours might indirectly discriminate against a disabled person unless the hours can be justified.
Discrimination arising from disability
It's discriminatory to treat someone less favourably because of something connected with their disability. For example, dismissing someone for making spelling mistakes owing to their dyslexia. It is justifiable only if the employer can show that it is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
This is treating someone less favourably because they associate with an individual who has a protected characteristic. For example, treating someone less favourably because their child has a disability and they sometimes have to leave work to deal with a problem.
This is treating someone less favourably because it’s perceived that they have a protected characteristic, whether they do or not. For example, refusing to appoint someone because it is thought that they are disabled when they’re not.
Victimisation occurs when someone is treated less favourably because they’ve made or supported a complaint, or raised a grievance under the Equality Act 2010. It also applies if it’s thought that they have made a complaint. A comparator isn’t required for a claim of victimisation. Post-employment victimisation can occur - for example refusing to give a reference to someone who had made a complaint under the Equality Act 2010 - although the Act has some grey areas concerning post-employment victimisation.
Harassment is ‘unwanted conduct related to a relevant protected characteristic, which has the purpose or effect of violating an individual’s dignity or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for that individual’.
There’s no longer any specific legislation making employers liable for harassment that comes from a third party (for example, a customer). However an employer can still be liable as a result of numerous other legal duties, for example breach of contract, direct discrimination and under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997. This, and good practice, mean that employers should continue to take steps to protect employees from all forms of harassment.
Find out more in our factsheet on workplace bullying and harassment.
Where there is an Occupational Requirement to employ a person with a particular protected characteristic, certain very limited exceptions from the law are permitted covering selection, promotion and training. The employer must be able to show that there's a genuine need, taking account of the type of work.
Case law in the area of disability discrimination continues to develop.
Employers can take positive action, for example to address under-representation or other forms of disadvantage within the workforce. The provisions are complex and must be handled very carefully. Different provisions apply concerning positive action relating to recruitment and promotion. See guidance from the EHRC.
Good employment practices
People professionals have a key role in creating fair and inclusive workplaces. As part of coherent diversity, inclusion and employee engagement strategies, employers should undertake thorough reviews or equality analyses of policies and working practices to remove unfair discrimination and bias. Feedback from employees with disabilities and long-term conditions is useful in developing an open and inclusive workplace culture.
Our stance on disability at work gives recommendations for employers, with additional information below.
Although there’s no legal requirement to have a written diversity and inclusion policy, it’s a good idea to produce and actively use one. In some discrimination claims, employers may have a defence if they can show that they took all reasonable steps to prevent the discrimination occurring. Having a comprehensive current policy and recent relevant training will help employers to distance themselves from liability for acts such as harassment by an individual perpetrator employed by them. A policy also demonstrates the organisation takes its legal and moral obligations towards being a diverse and inclusive employer seriously. It can also encourage employees to treat others equally.
Making reasonable adjustments
UK employers have a responsibility to make adjustments to accommodate the needs of a person with a disability. Employers are required to understand the barriers an employee is experiencing and put adjustments in place to resolve them. Employers should involve the employee in discussions about adjustments although the duty to make adjustments is ultimately the employer’s.
The legal requirement is to make adjustments that are ‘reasonable’. This duty falls to the organisation as a whole, not just a line manager in a department, so the resources (including finances and equipment) of the whole organisation need to be taken into account when deciding what is ‘reasonable’.
Reasonable adjustments must be considered with a specific individual and their specific role in mind. Adjustments can include :
- Altering premises – such as automated doors, providing ramps, quiet spaces, alternative formats of signage or directions around the building.
- Altering assessment procedures – such as giving extra time, providing assistive technology or ergonomic equipment.
- Training or mentoring – to support an employee to use new adjustments (such as speech to text software), or coping strategies (common with, for example, dyslexia or mental health conditions).
- Modified or specialist equipment – such as supportive chairs, height-adjustable or standing desks.
- Communication – providing an interpreter (for people who are, for example, deaf or who have a speech impairment).
- Time off during working hours – for example, for hospital appointments, physiotherapy, counselling, or treatment.
- Flexible working or adjusted hours.
A line manager along with the employee and, for example, occupational health, may come up with a range of adjustments that might remove the barrier the employee with a disability or condition is experiencing, but the employer needs to make an evidence-based decision if these adjustments are ‘reasonable’.
Pre-employment medical questionnaires
The Equality Act 2010 made it unlawful to issue pre-employment medical questionnaires, except in some limited circumstances. Before offering employment, health-related questions can only be asked to:
- Help decide if there's a need to make reasonable adjustments to the selection process.
- Help decide whether an applicant can carry out an essential part of the job.
- Monitor diversity amongst applicants.
- Take positive action to address a current under-representation among disabled people in the workforce.
- Ensure that an individual does have a disability if there's a genuine requirement for it (for example, a mental health counsellor being required to have experience of mental health issues).
Challenging stereotypical thinking
Stereotypical thinking and unaddressed unconscious bias can lead to bad decision-making. Employers should meet the needs of each employee with a disability or condition individually and identify solutions that will work for the person and the business.
- Disability shouldn't be confused with ill-health. Disability can affect health in different ways, and often is not health-related at all.
- Disability is broad and may not be visible or immediately obvious. For example, a very small percentage of people with disabilities are wheelchair users or Braille users.
- More people acquire their impairment or condition during their adult life than those who are born with them.
- A disability or condition can affect different people in different ways. Therefore, when making adjustments, consider the individual and their specific circumstances, not their condition.
- Corporate image and reputation can be seriously damaged or enhanced by the negative or positive experiences people with disabilities and their friends, families, and carers have of your organisation, especially with the increased use of social media and sites such as Glassdoor.
- Mental health problems affect a significant proportion of the population and stress-related illness has overtaken musculoskeletal conditions as the main cause of absence in the UK workforce as a whole.
- People with disabilities continue to find it significantly more difficult to get a job than able-bodied people, because employers fail to approach the management of disability positively.
- It’s possible to make simple changes to jobs and the way they’re carried out in order to successfully employ someone with a disability or long-term condition without serious cost, or even at no cost at all. Funding for workplace adjustments is available to most UK employers through Access to Work.
Recommendations for positive progress
Organisations should ensure line managers are appropriately trained with the skills to manage employees effectively and the knowledge to understand their legal obligations as well as their employer’s policy expectations. Disability ‘awareness’ training on its own is not enough: line managers need to know how to navigate conversations about disability and conditions with employees and understand what they need to do in order to arrange and implement adjustments.
The Department for Work and Pensions’ Disability Confident scheme has published, in collaboration with us and a panel of experts, a good practice guide for line managers on recruiting, managing and developing people with a disability or health condition. This includes practical tips for managers to help staff and colleagues feel comfortable to talk about a disability or health condition.
The Government has also launched a Voluntary Reporting framework encouraging employers to report what steps they are taking to support their disabled employees and promote employee health and well-being. It also provides direction and support to encourage employers to report the percentage of individuals in their organisation who have a disability or a long-term physical or mental health condition. The framework aims to help organisations make positive progress in successfully managing disability and fairness at work.
An action plan
- Review your organisation’s policy on disability in the workplace and your current process for making adjustments for employees. Identify whether it's fit-for purpose and effective in meeting the needs of the business whilst supporting employees.
- Review related existing policies and practices which may have an impact on employees with a disability or long term condition – for example, recruitment and selection, sickness and attendance, performance, grievance, bullying and harassment, and diversity and inclusion. Actively involving (not just passively 'listening' to) disabled people's views is a crucial part of reviewing existing policies and procedures, and understanding how they are being enacted by managers.
- Identify from this review an action plan for change and assign accountability to people in senior roles who can facilitate change.
- Follow good recruitment practice such as the Recruitment Charter launched by the Business Disability Forum. Our Recruitment factsheet also outlines good practice.
- Disability inclusion is a rapidly moving area with many UK businesses excelling in this field. Network with other employers who are developing disability-related workplace practices to share learning and experiences and keep up to date with good practice and legal developments.
Useful contacts and further reading
The following have resources and services to advise organisations or support people with disabilities in the workplace. There are many other organisations which offer detailed information and workplace advice about specific disabilities.
Disability Confident - a Government national level voluntary initiative to engage employer action in progressing inclusive policies and practices for people with disabilities, which is supported by the CIPD
The Disability ClearKit - developed in association with the Department for Work and Pensions, is the result of three years in-depth research with 220 leading employers
Books and reports
BUSINESS DISABILITY FORUM (2020) The great big workplace adjustments report. London: BDF.
COLEMAN, N., SYKES, W. and GROOM, C. (2013) Barriers to employment and unfair treatment at work: a quantitative analysis of disabled people's experiences. Research report 88. London: Equality and Human Rights Commission.
MENCAP (2017) Good for business: the benefits of employing people with a learning disability. London: Mencap.
REMPLOY (2017) Disability guide. London: Remploy. (Can be produced with company branding, either as a PDF or in print).
RUBENSTEIN, M. (2020) Discrimination: a guide to the relevant case law. 33rd ed. London: Michael Rubenstein Publishing.
BACON, N., HOGUE, K., WASS, V. and JONES, M. (2017) Are high performance work practices (HPWPs) enabling or disabling? Exploring the relationship between selected HPWPs and work-related disability disadvantage. Human Resource Management.
BEATTY, J. et al. (2019) On the treatment of persons with disabilities in organizations: a review and research agenda. Human Resource Management. Vol 58 No 2, March/April. Reviewed in In a Nutshell, issue 89.
BURT, E. (2019) One in four UK employers would not hire someone with a disability. People Management (online). 21 February.
CHURCHILL, F. (2020) Disabled workers facing coronavirus ‘jobs crisis’, survey shows. People Management (online). 27 October.
POWER, B. (2019) Disability, mental health and wellbeing reporting. People Management (online). 14 February.
SUFF, R. (2021) The Disability Employment Gap needs closing - on several fronts. CIPD Voice. Issue 27, 5 February.
CIPD members can use our online journals to find articles from over 300 journal titles relevant to HR.
Members and People Management subscribers can see articles on the People Management website.
This factsheet was last updated by Lisa Ayling, solicitor and employment law specialist, and Claire McCartney.
Claire McCartney: Senior Policy Adviser, Resourcing and Inclusion
Claire is the Resourcing and Inclusion Policy Adviser at the CIPD. For the last two years she has been running her own research and consultancy organisation.
Claire specialises in the areas of diversity & inclusion, flexible working, resourcing and talent management. She has also conducted research into meaning and trust at work, age diversity, workplace carers and enterprise and has worked on a number of international projects. She is the author of several reports and articles and regularly presents at seminars and conferences.
Prior to her roles at the CIPD, Claire was Principal Researcher at Roffey Park where she conducted research projects into a variety of topics including Roffey Park’s annual Management Agenda survey, work-life balance, flexible working, employee volunteering, talent management, and diversity. Claire has also worked with a range of clients on tailored research needs.
Explore our related content
Disability Confident employer
The CIPD is a Disability Confident Leader. We work with the DWP and lead the way in changing attitudes towards disability, and to encourage all employers to provide opportunities to ensure that people with disabilities and those with long-term health conditions are able to fulfil their potential at work. We regularly review our own people practices and approaches to ensure that our workplace is as open, diverse, accessible and inclusive as possible.