Here we list a selection of key cases, reported since 2010, on disputed or breached terms and conditions , providing a summary of the decision and implications for employers.

Cases have been grouped together based on the specific contractual issues being dealt with:

  • Express and implied terms
  • Unauthorised deductions
  • Variation of contract
  • Pay in lieu of notice - PILON
  • Restrictive covenants

Express and implied terms

Hershaw v Sheffield City Council | Employment Appeal Tribunal | 4 Nov 2014

Park Cakes Ltd v Shumba and others | Court of Appeal | 31 Jul 2013

Dresdner Kleinwort Ltd and another v Attrill and others | Court of Appeal | 26 Apr 2013

Smith v Trafford Housing Trust | High Court | 16 Nov 2012

Edwards v Chesterfield Royal Hospital NHS Foundation Trust | Supreme Court | 14 Dec 2011

Unauthorised deductions

Esparon v Slavikovska | Employment Appeal Tribunal | 8 May 2014

Variation of contract

Department of Transport v Sparks | Court of Appeal | 14 Apr 2016

Abercrombie v AGA Rangemaster Ltd | Court of Appeal | 11 Oct 2014

Pay in lieu of notice - PILON

Societe Generale v Raphael Geys | Supreme Court | 19 Dec 2012

Cavenagh v William Evans Ltd | Court of Appeal | 24 May 2012

Restrictive covenants

Threlfall v ECD Insight Ltd and another | High Court | 17 Dec 2012

Please note: While every care has been taken in compiling these notes, CIPD cannot be held responsible for any errors or omissions. These notes are not intended to be a substitute for specific legal advice.

Explore our related content


Contracts of employment

Introductory guidance to the contract of service, the written statement of particulars, and variations of the contractual terms

Read more