Episode 136: How biased are you? How unconscious bias plays into recruitment
Good recruitment is vital for every organisation - finding the right people for the right roles at the right time. It ensures that the workforce has the relevant skills and abilities for the organisation's current and future needs. Effective resourcing is not just about filling an immediate vacancy but about having an impact on the long-term success of the business, using workforce planning data to understand what skills are needed for organisational performance.
This factsheet looks at what recruitment and resourcing entails and outlines the UK law affecting recruitment activities. It describes the stages of the recruitment process: defining the role, including job analysis and job description; attracting the applicants using both internal and external methods; managing the selection process; and, finally, making the appointment and employment offer.
Effective resourcing and recruitment are crucial to the successful day-to-day functioning of any organisation. It depends upon finding people with the right skills, expertise and qualifications to deliver organisational objectives and to contribute positively to the values and aims of the business. Recruitment should also consider the future needs of the organisation, identifying individuals with potential for development.
Recruitment and resourcing professionals should always be aware of organisational strategy and the implications this has for resourcing. They also need to be fully aware of equal opportunities legislation and understand how discrimination can occur both directly and indirectly in the recruitment process.
Organisations should monitor their recruitment processes continuously to ensure their methods are effective, and that they are non-discriminatory, for both internal and external candidates.
Log in to view more
Log in to view more of this content. If you don't have a web account why not register to gain access to more of the CIPD's resources. Please note that some of our resources are for members only.
What is recruitment?
Recruitment and resourcing involve attracting and selecting individuals into a job role. Recruiting the right individuals is crucial to organisational performance, and is a critical activity, not just for the HR team but also for line managers who are increasingly involved in the selection process. All those involved in recruitment activities should be equipped with the appropriate knowledge and skills required to make effective and fair recruitment decisions.
The length and complexity of the recruitment process will vary depending on an organisation’s size and resources. However, the following stages should be present and are explored later in this factsheet:
- defining the role
- attracting applicants
- managing the application and selection process
- making the appointment.
Key considerations for recruitment and resourcing professionals
A variety of factors influence the recruitment market. Our quarterly Labour market outlook monitors UK economic and labour market indicators and recruitment outlook. Our Resourcing and talent planning survey provides data on UK recruitment trends and employers’ practices, including the expected impact of Brexit on resourcing. Although there’s considerable uncertainty about what the UK’s EU immigration policy will be following Brexit, potential changes to UK organisations' ability to recruit EU migrants is a key consideration for resourcing professionals. Our factsheet on employing overseas workers in the UK has more, and our Brexit hub has resources and details of our activities to support the HR profession.
Another key part of resourcing is attracting a diverse range of candidates. Diversity and inclusion should be considered at each stage of the process, with practices and systems regularly reviewed to ensure hidden bias is removed and resourcing methods are inclusive. Everyone taking part in activities such as shortlisting and interviewing should be aware of relevant legislation and the importance of avoiding discrimination. CIPD members can see our Recruitment and selection law Q&As for more on the UK legal aspects of recruitment. Our report Diversity and inclusion at work: facing up to the business case also highlights potential pitfalls to avoid in recruitment, and ways to tackle these.
Candidate experience is also important. The recruitment process is not just about employers identifying suitable employees, but candidates finding out more about the business and considering whether the organisation is one they would like to work for. First impressions matter, so effort should be made to ensure the process is transparent, timely and creates a good impression of the organisation, regardless of whether the candidate is successful or not. And, in a digital age where candidates can share their experiences online, inefficient, poorly designed recruitment processes have the potential to negatively impact on your employer brand and the ability to attract candidates.
Our new Profession Map sets out the specialist knowledge that resourcing professionals need to identify, attract and assess to get the right people for the organisation.
Defining the role
For both new and existing roles, it’s important to invest time in gathering information about the job from a variety of sources. This means thinking not only about the duties involved, but also the job’s purpose, how and where it can be carried out, the outputs required by the job holder and how it fits into the organisation’s structure. This analysis should form the basis of a job description and person specification/job profile.
The job analysis provides the information needed for the job description. This explains the requirements of the job to potential candidates and aids the recruitment process by providing a clear overview of the role for all involved. It can also be used to provide clarity during induction and later, on performance and objectives.
Person specification/job profile
A person specification or job profile states the necessary and desirable criteria for selection. The characteristics specified must be clear, demonstrable and avoid bias in wording.
Competency frameworks are sometimes substituted for job or person specifications, but these should include an indication of roles and responsibilities. See our factsheet on competence and competency frameworks.
There are many ways to generate interest from potential candidates.
Employee referral schemes
Some organisations operate an employee referral scheme. These schemes usually offer an incentive to existing employees to assist in the recruitment of friends or contacts. But employers should not rely on such schemes at the expense of attracting a diverse workforce and they should complement other attraction methods.
Our Resourcing and talent planning surveys identify common ways of attracting candidates including employer’s website, commercial job boards, recruitment agencies, and professional networking sites such as LinkedIn (although this will vary by sector and seniority).
Other common ways to attract applications include building links with local colleges/universities, working with the local jobcentre and using local networks. Using multiple and non-traditional outreach methods widens the talent pool.
Most candidates expect able to search and apply for jobs online, meaning employers need to pay attention to their corporate website and their online employer brand. Many organisations also use social media to identify candidates, but employers need to exercise caution - see more in our report Putting social media to work: lessons from employers.
Candidates and organisations should also be aware of the increase in fraudulent online job adverts, where fraudsters post a false role on job boards, posing as a legitimate organisation in order to ask applicants to pay for online checks or training. Safer Jobs can provide advice and support.
Advertisements should be contain clear, accurate information and the organisation and the role. They should also indicate:
- the organisation’s activities and values
- job requirements and other criteria
- job location
- reward and benefits package
- flexible working opportunities, where available
- type of employment offered. For example, is it a fixed-term role?
- details of how to apply and the deadline.
External recruitment services
Some organisations use external providers to help with their resourcing and recruitment. Recruitment agencies or consultants offer a range of services such as attracting candidates, managing candidate responses, screening and shortlisting, or running assessment centres on the employer’s behalf. They need to have a good understanding of the organisations and its requirements. These services might also be provided by an outsourcing provider - find out more in our HR outsourcing factsheet.
It’s important not to forget the internal talent pool when recruiting. Providing opportunities for development and career progression can aid retention and supports succession planning. For more, see our talent management factsheet.
Managing the application and selection process
There are two main formats in which paper or online applications are likely to be received: a curriculum vitae (CV) and covering letter or an application form. Some organisations allow candidates to apply with their LinkedIn profile.
Throughout the application and selection process, reasonable adjustments may need to be made for candidates.
Application forms allow for information to be presented in a consistent format. This makes it easier to collect information from job applicants in a systematic way and assess objectively the candidate’s suitability for the job.
However, an unnecessarily long or poorly-designed application form can mean applications from good candidates are overlooked, or that candidates are put off applying, so the design and language used is important. It may be necessary to offer application forms in different formats to comply with discrimination law.
CVs and LinkedIn profiles
The advantage of CVs or LinkedIn profiles is that candidates are not restricted to a standard application form. However, CVs and LinkedIn profiles may include surplus material and vary in format which undermines their consistent assessment.
All applications should be treated confidentially and circulated only to those individuals involved in the recruitment process.
Prompt acknowledgment of an application - whether successful or unsuccessful - is good practice and presents a positive image of the organisation.
Selecting candidates involves two main processes: shortlisting those who have the necessary skills to proceed to assessment stage, and assessing those candidates to ascertain who is most suitable for the role. See more on this stage in our selection methods factsheet which covers the various techniques and tools available to employers, and the importance of using valid and reliable selection methods.
Making the appointment
Before making an offer of employment, employers have responsibility for checking that applicants have the right to work in the UK and have the appropriate qualifications or credentials. See more in our factsheet on employing overseas workers in the UK and our guide to pre-employment checks.
References are most frequently sought after the applicant has been given a ‘provisional offer’. Any recruitment policy should state clearly how references will be used, when in the recruitment process they will be taken up and what kind of references will be necessary (for example, from former employers).
These rules should be applied consistently, and candidates should always be informed of the procedure for taking up references.
CIPD members can find out more on the UK legal aspects in our References law Q&As.
Medical questionnaires and making reasonable adjustments
In the UK, the Equality Act 2010 makes it unlawful to ask candidates to complete a medical questionnaire before being offered a job. Only essential medical issues should be discussed at this stage. See more in our factsheet on disability and employment.
However, any necessary physical or medical requirement should be made clear in the job advertisement or other recruitment literature.
Employers need to think creatively and innovatively about where they can make reasonable adjustments, such as flexible working arrangements or providing specialist equipment, where someone has a disability.
Offers of employment should always be made in writing. But it is important to be aware that a verbal offer of employment made in an interview is as legally binding as a letter to the candidate. See more in our contracts of employment factsheet. CIPD members can use our Terms and conditions of employment law Q&As.
Unsuccessful candidates should be notified promptly in writing and every effort should be made to provide feedback. If psychometric tests are used, feedback on the results, delivered by a qualified person, should also be offered.
Joining the organisation
Well-planned induction enables new employees to become fully operational quickly and should be integrated into the recruitment process. See more in our induction factsheet.
Documentation and evaluation
The recruitment process should be documented accurately, and access limited to recruitment staff for confidentiality reasons. The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) means that recruitment process and applicant tracking systems may need review - see our data protection factsheet.
Information should be kept for sufficient time to allow any complaints to be handled - our factsheet on retaining HR records has guidance on how long records should be kept.
It’s good practice to monitor applications and recruitment decisions to ensure that equality of opportunity is being allowed. Where issues are highlighted in the process, action should be taken.
Using metrics such as cost of hire, candidate experience ratings and time to hire can also provide insight into the effectiveness of recruitment processes. Our HR and standards factsheet has information on standards relating to recruitment, such as cost of hire and workforce planning.
Useful contacts and further reading
Books and reports
ACAS. (2018) Recruiting staff. London: Acas.
GOVERNMENT EQUALITIES OFFICE. (2011) Equality Act 2010: What do I need to know? A quick start guide to using positive action in recruitment and promotion. London: GEO.
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR THE CARE AND RESETTLEMENT OF OFFENDERS (NACRO). (2015) Recruiting fairly and safely: a practical guide to employing ex-offenders. London: Nacro.
NEWELL-BROWN, J. (2014) The professional recruiter's handbook: delivering excellence in recruitment practice. 2nd ed. London: Kogan Page.
TAYLOR, S. (2014) Resourcing and talent management. 6th ed. London: Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development.
Visit the CIPD and Kogan Page Bookshop to see all our priced publications currently in print.
ACIKGOZ, Y. (2019) Employee recruitment and job search: towards a multi-level integration. Human Resource Management Review. Vol 29, No 1. pp1-13.
BROWN, P. (2018) It’s time to put data at the heart of the recruitment process. People Management (online). 13 February.
INGOLD, J. and VALIZADE, D. (2017) Employers’ recruitment of disadvantaged groups: exploring the effect of active labour market programme agencies as labour market intermediaries. Human Resource Management Journal. Vol 27, No 4. pp530-547. Reviewed in In a Nutshell, issue 73.
JEFFREY, R. (2017) Would you let AI recruit for you? People Management (online). 12 December.
CIPD members can use our online journals to find articles from over 300 journal titles relevant to HR.
Members and People Management subscribers can see articles on the People Management website.
This factsheet was last updated by Melanie Green.
Melanie Green: Research Adviser
Melanie joined the CIPD in 2017, specialising in learning & development and skills research. Prior to the CIPD, Mel worked as an HR practitioner in a technology organisation, working on a variety of learning and development initiatives, and has previously worked as a researcher in an employee engagement and well-being consultancy.
Melanie holds a master’s degree in Occupational Psychology from University of Surrey, where she conducted research into work–life boundary styles and the effect of this on employee well-being and engagement.
Explore our related content
Provides practical tips for avoiding bias in recruitment, attracting applicants, improving the candidate experience, and making better hiring decisions
An overview of candidate assessment methods, focusing on interviews, psychometric tests and assessment centres, as part of the recruitment process.
Highlighting the key checks carried out during the recruitment process and explaining the risks and practical considerations to be taken into account when offering employment