A look at how transformational change themes apply in practice, with case studies providing practical examples
Organisational change is a constant in organisations today and can be driven by a number of different forces, including customers, markets and technology. Yet research shows that most change initiatives fail to accomplish their intended outcomes and may even limit the potential of an organisation and its people. The consequences of not managing change effectively can be devastating and long lasting, so it’s important that HR and L&D professionals understand the potential issues and equip themselves with techniques to support change-management initiatives.
This factsheet looks at why change management is important, the implications of not managing change effectively, and the potential issues that can arise in change-management processes. The factsheet also offers a series of techniques to help ensure effective change management.
Frequent organisational change is the norm, yet the high levels of failure indicate that effective change management remains an issue. There’s no single model of change and no single solution to effective management, but HR and L&D professionals are recognising they need to ensure they have the skills, knowledge and credibility within their organisation to be champions of change.
HR has a clear role and responsibility to ensure that issues like organisation (re)design, due process, employee voice, and clear communications are appropriately and effectively addressed as part of change management. L&D professionals also have a critical role to play in ensuring the long-term sustainability of a change, through effective design and delivery of learning initiatives. The key for HR and L&D is to build credible relationships throughout the organisation which enable them to anticipate, design and lead the business through change. As the experts on people, work and change, our profession has a responsibility to uphold good practice principles during change initiatives, in order to find sustainable solutions which balance the needs of the different stakeholders involved.
Why organisations need to change
Many things cause organisational change. These include:
- challenges of growth, especially global markets
- economic downturns and tougher trading conditions
- changes in strategy
- technological changes
- competitive pressures, including mergers and acquisitions
- customer pressure, particularly shifting markets
- learning new organisation behaviours and skills
- government legislation/initiatives.
All organisations are in flux: changing their focus, expanding or contracting their activities and rethinking their products and services. This is particularly true during times of significant economic uncertainty; for example following the vote by the UK to leave the EU in June 2016 - see our Brexit hub. In the wake of the global financial crisis and recent corporate scandals, organisations are becoming increasingly concerned with developing a more balanced view of their stakeholders, and taking a long-term perspective in decision-making. Furthermore, technology is driving new forms of employment relationship and fundamentally changing the way businesses operate. In order to remain competitive in such a climate of uncertainty, agility has become a business priority.
In this context, managers have to be able to introduce and manage change to ensure the organisational objectives of change are met, and that they gain the commitment of their people, both during and after implementation. Often, at the same time, they also have to ensure that business continues as usual.
For these reasons, it’s important that the way change is managed is considered carefully. Whilst each change situation will be unique, there are still a number of common themes that will help ensure that the change process stands the greatest chance of success
Find out about Megatrends - our research into the biggest changes of recent times.
Why managing change is important
Change management matters because, although change is taking place at an ever-increasing pace, there is evidence to suggest that most change initiatives fail. For example, our research finds that less than 60% of re-organisations met their stated objectives which are usually bottom line improvement.
Failure to introduce effective change can have a high impact: loss of market position, removal of senior management, loss of stakeholder credibility, loss of key employees, and reduction in employee engagement.
One organisational response to change is that organisational forms are themselves evolving. Therefore, the change management response will have to be adaptive. For example, the increased competitive challenges and the need to be responsive to the changing environment are resulting in emerging organisational models. Traditional organisational models following functional or matrix lines are being supplemented by new models that rely on project teams, on networks and on virtual structures.
In theory, some of these newer models, for example virtual and project-based structures, allow increased flexibility to respond to change. However such models are not always introduced uniformly, and in practice often introduce other issues that also impact upon change management, for example ability to share knowledge and to operate efficiently. These may also impact effectiveness of communication or employee commitment, which themselves have implications for change effectiveness.
Our research series Beyond the organisation explores how the move towards network-based organisations means that HR managers must now consider issues that exist across and outside the boundaries of the firm. This requires the development of a series of boundary spanning HRM practices and means that many groups must be considered in times of change.
Issues in the change management process
A number of key issues have a negative impact on effective change management.
Individual change initiatives are not always undertaken as part of a wider coherent change plan, for example through considering linkages between strategy, structure and systems issues. Therefore a change that considers a new structure but fails to establish the need to introduce new systems or processes to support such a structure is less likely to succeed.
Lack of effective project management and programme management disciplines can lead to slippages in timings, achieving desired outcomes and in ensuring that the projects do deliver as planned. Insufficient, relevant training, for example in project management, change management and leadership skills, can all impact negatively on the effectiveness of any change initiative.
Poor communication can be linked to issues surrounding the effectiveness of change management in achieving effective change in various ways. For example, imposed change can lead to greater employee resistance (see below).
Change initiatives can also be over-managed, with too much energy spent on project management and too little on enacting change.
Finally, lack of effective leadership is an inhibitor of effective change.
Individual/group resistance to change
Resistance to change can be defined as an individual or group engaging in acts to block or disrupt an attempt to introduce change. Resistance is not necessarily negative, as it may be a clear signal that the change initiative requires rethinking or reframing (see below). Resistance itself can take many different forms from subtle undermining of change initiatives and withholding of information to active resistance, for instance through strikes.
There are two broad types of resistance:
- Resistance to the content of change. For example to a specific change in technology, or to the introduction of a particular reward system.
- Resistance to the process of change. This concerns the way a change is introduced rather than the object of change in itself. For example, management re-structure of jobs without prior consultation of affected employees.
Proposed reasons for resistance include: loss of control, shock of the new, uncertainty, inconvenience, threat to status and competence fears. It is important not to assume that resistance is negative, and to try to diagnose the cause of employee resistance as this will help determine the focus of effort in trying to address the issue.
Our Neuroscience in action research suggests that ‘resistance to change’ may in fact be a deep rooted threat response, designed to keep us safe.
Making change management more effective
It’s clear that change is complex and there isn’t a single solution to managing it. However, a number of key areas of focus emerge. Our transformational change research, in collaboration with the University of Bath, identifies ten techniques, across three themes, which can be applied to a variety of change management scenarios to enhance the effectiveness of change programmes.
Designing the transformation
Reading and rewriting the context
Leaders and designers of change need to be able to ‘read’ their context; to evaluate it to identify aspects that hinder change. They then need to design change programmes which first put in place initiatives to rewrite or rewire their context in a way that overcomes obstacles to enable the desired change.
Aligning strategy and culture
For transformation to succeed, designers of change need to align strategic and cultural aspirations. Using the new strategic goals of the organisation as a starting point, they need to identify a new supportive and goal-consistent culture in terms of beliefs and behaviours.
Radical change opportunistically
If open discussion and debate is encouraged in the top team this enables more proactive, opportunistic change to happen, as executives become more open to breaking with the past and transitioning out old business models as they become irrelevant.
Techniques for building understanding
Ambiguity and purposeful instability
Transformation can be facilitated if a change vision is ambitious yet also presented in ambiguous terms, with the deliberate intent of encouraging individuals to actively question and attempt to make sense of their situation.
Narratives, storytelling and conversations
Narratives and stories can be used as devices to make the content and implications of new strategies easier to understand, enhancing individuals’ ability to translate change into meaningful actions for themselves.
Physical representations, metaphors and play
Use of objects, metaphors, symbols and pictures - maybe as part of playful design as an alternative to traditional and often rather dry change workshops - helps to engage individuals and to enable them to translate change rhetoric into meaningful change-related actions.
Managing the transformation
Rather than implementing change through authority and control, in new forms of leadership transformational change is achieved through negotiations and social interactions with organisational members.
High levels of trust will deliver the enabling conditions in which significant change can thrive. Change leaders need to emphasise their trustworthiness by demonstrating their competence to design change intelligently, and their benevolence and integrity in the way they attend to the needs of the business, employees and the wider community. HR and L&D systems and processes designed and administered in a fair way, help foster trustworthiness in the organisation.
Voice, dialogue and rethinking resistance
In more democratic workplaces, the actions of employees who raise concerns about change should not be labelled as resistance, but instead reframed and reinterpreted in terms of legitimacy of employee voice.
Emotion, energy and momentum
Change is often an emotional process and so emotional awareness by those leading and designing change is required to anticipate and plan for reactions. Those managing the change must also maintain levels of energy and momentum throughout the change process.
HR and L&D’s role in managing change
Our transformational change research, with the University of Bath, explores HR and L&D’s role in managing change though four case study organisations.
The research demonstrates that people management and development professionals have a significant role to play in any change management process. They often act as ‘stage directors of change’ playing a critical role behind the scenes – appreciated by all, but not front of stage. The report provides a number of recommendations that HR professionals should consider if they are to be successful expert initiators and facilitators of transformational change:
- Be willing to work as the ‘hidden hand’ of change, highly relevant to its success. Work in partnership with the CEO/business leader and their executive team and as ‘back stage’ support for their ‘front stage’ activity.
- Facilitate translation of the overall vision through mass communication, use of relevant techniques, and changes to interactions and entrenched systems.
- Create change advocates, remove obstacles, act on measurement and ensure leader visibility.
Listen to our Landing transformational change podcast.
HR and L&D professionals will often experience a conflict of interests between the business and employees, when leading and managing change. The ability to apply situational judgement and demonstrate moral integrity is what will enable them to be trusted advisors, and help the organisation create long-term sustainability. Since HR is responsible for making decisions that affect workers’ lives, it’s important that practitioners have confidence in upholding professional standards when faced with difficult situations - see our report on professional identity. Our Professional Standards Framework creates clear standards for HR and L&D professionals at every level, helping them to champion better work and working lives.
CAMERON, E. AND GREEN, M. (2012) Making sense of change management: a complete guide to the models, tools and techniques of organisational change. 3rd ed. London: Kogan Page.
HUGHES, M. (2010) Managing change: a critical perspective. 2nd ed. London: Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development.
On change management. HBR’s 10 must reads (2011) Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
Visit the CIPD and Kogan Page Bookshop to see all our priced publications currently in print.
AGUIRRE, D. and ALPERN, M. (2014) 10 principles of leading change management. Strategy+Business. No 75, Summer. pp65-71.
ALFES, K., TRUSS, C. and GILL, J. (2010). The HR manager as change agent: evidence from the public sector. Journal of Change Management. Vol 10, No 1. pp.109-127.
BARRATT-PUGH, L. and BAHN, S. (2015) HR strategy during culture change: building change agency. Journal of Management & Organization. Vol 21, No 6. pp.741-754.
GRAETZ, F. and SMITH, A. (2010) Managing organizational change: a philosophies of change approach. Journal of Change Management. Vol10, No 2, June. pp135-154.
LAWRENCE, P. (2015) Leading change: insights into how leaders actually approach the challenge of complexity. Journal of Change Management. Vol 15, No 3. pp231-252.
WIEDNER, R., BARRETT, M. and OBORN, E. (2017) The emergence of change in unexpected places: resourcing across organizational practices in strategic change. Academy of Management Journal. Vol 60, No 3. pp823-854.
CIPD members can use our online journals to find articles from over 300 journal titles relevant to HR.
Members and People Management subscribers can see articles on the People Management website.
This factsheet was last updated by Louisa Baczor.
Louisa Baczor: Research Adviser
Louisa joined the CIPD in 2015, specialising in research for the CIPD’s Profession for the Future programme. This research explored what it means to be a professional, key drivers impacting the future of work, and how practitioners apply ethical principles when making people management decisions.
Louisa’s current research is investigating the future of voice in the workplace, and how organisations can enable people to have a meaningful voice at work. Prior to this, she worked on workplace well-being, employability, and professional identity streams.
With an undergraduate degree in psychology, Louisa studied the changing roles of HR and impact on trust during a Master’s at the University of Bath.
Explore our related content
Episode 107: This episode explores the critical role of HR and OD professionals in leading change and becoming expert facilitators as well as discussing the experiences of organisations who are getting it right.
Episode 84: With organisations facing near constant change, this episode focuses on strategies for organisational design and development and how involving stakeholders and effective communication is key to smooth implementation.
A focus on the key trends shaping our economies and the world of work